Improved Probability-Weighted Moments and Two-Stage Order Statistics Methods of Generalized Extreme Value Distribution

Abstract

This study evaluates six parameter estimation methods for the generalized extreme value (GEV) distribution: maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), two probability-weighted moments (PWM-UE and PWM-PP), and three robust two-stage order statistics estimators (TSOS-ME, TSOS-LMS, and TSOS-LTS). Their performance was assessed using simulation experiments under varying tail behaviors, represented by three types of GEV distributions: Weibull (short-tailed), Gumbel (light-tailed), and Fréchet (heavy-tailed) distributions, based on the mean squared error (MSE) and mean absolute percentage error (MAPE). The results showed that TSOS-LTS consistently achieved the lowest MSE and MAPE, indicating high robustness and forecasting accuracy, particularly for short-tailed distributions. Notably, PWM-PP performed well for the light-tailed distribution, providing accurate and efficient estimates in this specific setting. For heavy-tailed distributions, TSOS-LTS exhibited superior estimation accuracy, while PWM-PP showed a better predictive performance in terms of MAPE. The methods were further applied to real-world monthly maximum PM2.5 data from three air quality stations in Bangkok. TSOS-LTS again demonstrated superior performance, especially at Thon Buri station. This research highlights the importance of tailoring estimation techniques to the distribution’s tail behavior and supports the use of robust approaches for modeling environmental extremes.